For that price, I'd go for it...
I almost bought a new Mini S before I decided last minute to go fore the MX5 Club. I test drove a couple Minis and they are OK - things I didn't like - auto blip, fake exhaust sound, and it just felt kind of sluggish compared to the the Miata (but most things do anyway). Still, the Mini was cool, but once I test drove the Miata, it was an instant decision.