
Originally Posted by
Raza
Well, in this scenario, I still have a Z4, and then eventually an M Roadster. So I'm not looking for my fixed roof car to be crazy hardcore. I want something I can drive in snow and take to the shops without worrying about whether everything in the shopping cart will fit in the trunk (I just came back from Sam's, it's a real worry). It has to be a manual, AWD strongly preferred, and it needs a harder edge than your basic Audi. And as I discovered driving my brother's S4, I very much prefer a mechanical handbrake.
That leads me to the Evo, STI, and WRX. But since I'm going used, the WRX is sort of a distant third. GTI (new) and whatever Golf R is available at the time is also a possibility (much more grown up than the other two, but also very rare unless they change it in the future).
As for the leather and sunroof...well, I hate cloth seats and I'm a convertible driver--a car with a steel roof that doesn't let any light in would feel like a cage. I've never owned a fixed roof car without a sunroof or leather (or leatherette, which is fine by me). Just can't do cloth and steel. I don't smoke in fixed roof cars, but still, the discomfort of cloth and the fact that it picks up every smell is annoying. I MIGHT be able to deal with it in these cars, but no sunroof is a deal breaker for sure.